Roland Berger study reveals why Australian companies struggle with AI conversion

05 October 2026 Consultancy.com.au 4 min. read

More than a third of Australian companies are yet to see a return on their AI investments according to a new report from global strategy consultancy Roland Berger, the highest rate in the Asia Pacific.

The survey quizzed more than 200 company execs across seven major regional economies, including Singapore, China, Japan, South Korea, Indonesia and India, and then classified their AI adoption, investment, and maturity levels into one of four performance categories.

At 37 percent, Australia had by far the highest rate of what Roland Berger termed as ‘stalled’ companies – those which had invested but so far failed to achieve any real value – but also the equal highest ratio of those which had done so, suggesting the market or adoption isn’t the issue.

Source: Roland Berger

In all, 27 percent of the Australian companies surveyed were found to have moved beyond AI initiatives and pilots into deployments which had delivered measurable business results – classed as ‘industrialisers’ – a figure which ranked alongside China and Japan at the head of the pack, whereas China and Japan’s share of ‘stalled’ companies in contrast sits at 30 percent or well below.

To further illustrate Australia’s relative standing as an ‘advanced’ AI market, almost three quarters of the South Korea companies were still at the ‘observers’ stage – that is, experimenting but yet to progress to broad adoption or consistent results – while also having the highest ratio of ‘specialists’ demonstrating strong results from targeted initiatives, ten points above Australia at 13 percent.

Source: Roland Berger

While some of the contrast with its regional peers can be attributed to Australia’s service-led economy, as opposed to manufacturing, it’s clear that local companies have an appetite for AI. This notion is backed by seven of ten having a genuine belief that AI is ‘transformative’, and a third of Aussie respondents stating their plans to increase AI spending in the next year, some significantly.

So what then sets Australian ‘industrialisers’ from ‘stalled’ companies apart in converting AI adoption to value, given both sets are enthusiastically investing and broadly operating within the same market context, with comparative executive buy-in, strong governance, and mature digital infrastructure? Roland Berger’s survey analysis reveals several potential contributing factors.

Source: Roland Berger

One issue may be in their approach to measuring the value of AI itself, with three quarters of the ‘industrialiser’ cohort also adopting continuous ROI monitoring tools such as live dashboards, as against just over a third of those struggling. An even sharper divide can be seen in the volume of proofs which move through to production, although that may relate to selectivity in the first place.

While a lack of operational discipline is an evident determinant, aspiration may sit at the heart of the matter. Over 90 percent of those unable to unlock value are primarily using AI to augment existing processes, rather than redesigning them around autonomy. On the flip side, three quarters of the ‘AI leaders’ are pursuing deeper transformation, compared to less than 10 percent elsewhere.

“Our report shows that Australia is caught in somewhat of an AI paradox, with the highest share of stalled companies in the region,” says co-author and recent partnership recruit Nawaz Isaji. “So, to unlock the next frontier of growth, business leaders must move past treating AI as merely a shiny add-on to existing processes, and really start completely redesigning work around AI.”